June 16, 2017

Hometown Hero Frank Gehry


Frank Gehry LARB Event Susan Morse House
photo credit Susan Cloke

Hometown Hero: Frank Gehry
SUSAN CLOKE
Columnist, Santa Monica Mirror
June 16, 2017

Frank Gehry likes to say, “You know, I’m 88.”  He was born in Toronto, Canada in 1929.  As one of only 30 Jewish families in town at that time, he often found himself called names and physically attacked. 

Gehry is now a ‘starchitect’ - a label given to the current group of world famous architects who have variously expressed the culture, angst and beauty of our time through their architecture.  It is a label he does not seek. “I’m still in my head the outsider and I feel comfortable there. I like it there,” says Gehry.

Santa Monicans will have seen his new house, under construction on Adelaide, built for his wife Berta and designed by their son Sam with a lot of kibitzing from Frank.  The front form holds one bedroom, a living room, a dining room and a family room.  The back form holds two guest rooms and a small caretaker’s apartment, a music room and the garage.  The house boasts an impressive use of geothermal energy. Gehry applauds the environmental benefits but deplores the cost. He thinks as costs decrease the use of geothermal energy will become mainstream.

“The chain link in the front is only temporary,” said Gehry - a tongue-in-cheek reference to his house on Washington and 22nd in Santa Monica.  Built in the 1970’s, his use of chain link and other ubiquitous materials to build this “inside/outside” house made him both revered and scorned.  
Gehry Adelaide House 2017

On a banner sunshine-into-dusk day, with the Pacific sparkling in the background, people gathered to hear the Architecture Critic Joseph Giovannini interview Frank Gehry.  The LARB (Los Angeles Review of Books) sponsored event was held in the home of architect and painter Susan Morse.  

Giovannini introduced Gehry saying, “He is a world historical figure.”  Giovannini’s introduction is supported by Gehry’s work.   A partial list includes the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain; the Frederick R. Weisman Art Museum at the University of Minnesota; the Richard B. Fisher Center for the Performing Arts at Bard College, in Annandale-on-Hudson, NY; the Disney Concert Hall in Los Angeles, CA; Opus Residential Tower in Hong Kong; Foundation Louis Vuitton in Paris, France: and the Boulez Hall in Berlin, Germany.

Gehry’s interest is currently focused on the LA River Project.  Asked by LA Mayor Garcetti, Gehry is working, pro bono, on a study of the River.  “The thrust of what has happened so far is habitat and recreation,” said Gehry. 

“The ideal,” said Gehry, “is to divert water during storms and return it to the river or clean it and return it to the aquifer.”

Gehry wanted to understand the communities along the 51 miles of the LA River.  As part of this work he prepared an index of public health issues, specifically through South LA to where the LA River meets the ocean in Long Beach.  Gehry found staggering numbers recording high health risks of diseases that public health officials correlate with limited open space and few recreational activities.

Gehry studied reports from the Army Corps of Engineers to gain understanding of the engineering challenges of the LA River project.  The Corps now also supports habitat and restoration of the LA River and ties the LA River project to environmental quality.
Tension and conflict in the LA River project come with locating available land, which is difficult in some areas, and flooding which is always dangerous. “Hard not to get stuck,” Gehry mused, “Where to go?”  

Gehry is turning his attention to the Boyle Heights part of the LA River thinking, “If you could build a park it would connect the City.” 

Continuing his interest in education he is contributing to a Michelle Obama program for Arts in the Schools. “Melissa Shriver runs our program and we now have 14 schools we fund where we bring arts to the classroom. It is similar to my work in the 70’s on a program directed by my sister, Doreen Gehry Nelson, called Design Based Learning.”

Gehry describes one class where “David Hockney came to Menlo Park.  He brought vases and flowers, arranged them, drew on the computer and projected the drawings on a wall.  60% of the children in the class were homeless.  We gave them each a computer and they then made their own drawings which are now on display at Zuckerberg’s office.”  (Zuckerberg funded this project.)

From schools in California to music in Germany, Gehry continues to use his status and his art to create buildings and to work for world changing communities.  In Berlin, working with Daniel Barenboim, Gehry designed the Pierre Boulez Saal where young Arab and Israeli musicians could train together with the combined idea of creating music and creating hope for the future of the Middle East.

The journalist Joseph Morgenstern, writing for the NYT in 1982, said about Gehry, “Even in California, where idiosyncrasy is a mass movement, Frank O. Gehry is in a class by himself. He is the most important architect in the state, indeed in the West.”  That was 1982.  He is now one of the most important architects in the world.  Gehry’s work expands the definition of starchitect to include a person who uses skill, knowledge and position to make a more interesting, more fun and safer world.










April 20, 2017

The March for Science: Santa Monicans on the Issues of the March





The March for Science: Santa Monicans on the Issues of the March
Susan Cloke. Columnist. Santa Monica Mirror
April 21, 2017

The Los Angeles March for Science is one of over 500 Science Marches taking place in the U.S. and around the world on Earth Day, April 22, 2017. 

The organizers of the March write, “Science, scientists, and evidence-based policymaking are under attack.  Budget cuts, censorship of researchers, disappearing data sets, and threats to dismantle government agencies harm us all, putting our health, food, air, water, climate, and jobs at risk.”   
Agreeing with the concerns stated is Anton Bilchik, M.D. of the John Wayne Cancer Center in Santa Monica.

Dr. Bilchik, a renowned cancer researcher and surgical oncologist said,
“My understanding is that there is a purposed 20% cut in funding for NIH (National Institute of Health) research.  The consequences of that are massive. There will be fewer research studies and fewer clinical trials.  It will slow the process of developing new treatments and new detection methods and surgical quality measures.  

“The impact is on cancer centers, universities, training of new doctors and specialists and the long term inevitability of people not wanting to go into research because there will be no reasonable expectation of funding.

“One of the most exciting areas in cancer therapy is immunotherapy, over the past 5 years there has been enormous progress changing how we treat cancer - breakthroughs made possible by research supported by NIH.

From medicine to sustainability, scientists in every field are concerned.  Mark Gold, D.Env, is best known as the first Director of HTB (Heal the Bay)
He is currently Vice Chancellor of the Institute of the Environment and Sustainability at UCLA

Gold spoke about being at the 25,000 person conference of the American Geophysical Union in San Francisco in December of 2016, remembering, “There was a palpable anxiety about the future of scientific research in the face of the denial of the importance and value of science by President Trump.

“The thought of science on the chopping block in Trump’s proposed budget is nothing less than horrifying.”

Sarah Sikich is the current Vice President of HTB.  She holds a master’s degree in environmental science and a bachelor’s in marine biology.

“We are at a tipping point for climate change and for water protection.
With the Trump Administration questioning the importance of science and the reality of climate change we have to say it is irresponsible not to use science in the protection of our nation.

“HTB scientists’ research on the level of harmful bacteria present in the Santa Monica Bay and the frequency and severity of sicknesses for swimmers and surfers helped to lay the foundation for environmental laws and regulations that have dramatically improved the water quality of the Bay. 

“As an environmental organization whose work is based on science HTB
believes we have to be part of the Angeleno community coming together to let President Trump, all our elected leaders and the entire Federal Government know they must use science in governing.”

Joining in the protection of science and research is the NRDC’s (Natural Resources Defense Council) Water Director and Senior Attorney, Steve Fleishli.

“The new administration has expressed such disdain for science.  There is a fundamental assail on science which threatens our work to understand and combat climate change and water quality.

“Fortunately we still have a system of checks and balances.  Trump cannot rule by fiat.  He can’t undo laws with a wave of a magic wand.

NRDC is in litigation against the EPA for illegally rescinding the rule regulating discharges of mercury - a neurotoxin that can harm the nervous system and on the refusal to ban the pesticide chlorpyrifos - linked to learning disabilities in children.

“I am confident we will prevail. While we are already moving against the Trump administration, the court process is slow and tremendous damage could be done in the interval.”

California is a world leader in biomedical research, technology, renewable energy, water conservation, environmental protections.  Innovation based in science.  

President Trump can’t tweet away facts.  The facts are that climate change is real, world temperatures are rising, oceans are rising.

Global climate change is a race.  Waiting out the Trump administration is not an option.   On an individual scale, biomedical research saves lives.  We are poised at a great moment in medicine.  Now is the time for science.  Now is the time for the democratic resistance.


Los Angeles March   http://marchforsciencela.com/
Date: April 22, 2017
Location: Pershing Square Park
Time: 9AM - 4PM














January 22, 2017

Women's March on Washington January 21, 2017







Women’s March On Washington
SUSAN CLOKE
January 21, 2017



This is What Democracy Looks Like” chanted the hundreds of thousands of women I marched with on Saturday, January 21 in Washington DC.  

We were talking about ourselves; women, men, all colors, all ages, people of all religions, from all countries, of all sexual identities.

It was the day after the inauguration of Donald Trump as President of the U.S. and women were reeling from the election of a person with his misogynistic and racist view of the world.

But make no mistake.  The March, which ended in front of the White House, was not about Trump.  It was about the empathic and compassionate values of democracy.  Women, and the many men who were at the March, carried signs they had made calling for human rights, health care, education and protection of the environment.

Signs were the manifesto of the March.

With self-deprecating humor and real defiance hundreds of thousands of marchers wore hand knitted pink pussy hats.

“P**** Grabs Back,” said signs made in outraged response to Trump’s, on tape, self-admitted groping assaults on women’s genitals.




Women are mightily offended by Donald Trump, by his assumption that women are fair game for his unwanted advances, his rating system and his self-admitted sexual assaults.  

Offense becomes defiance at the threat of taking away women’s rights to control their own bodies.  “My Body, My Rights.”  

Signs spoke to issues and values: Black Lives Matter, Voter Suppression, Russian influence on the U.S. election, Environmental Protection, Climate Change, Standing Rock,  Public Education, Criminal Justice, Bridges Not Walls. 

The serious messages of the signs mixed with the joyful spirit of the crowd.  Marchers were wonderfully patient and kind.  There were too many people to be able to reach the stage on the Mall and hear the speakers and singers.  The crowd overflowed the Mall, it was too big for the designated March route.  Calmly taking to adjacent streets, people found their own way to the White House.  

The point of the March was made and everyone knew it.  This march took people past election shock and into action.  People were going to stand up for democracy, for values of equality and inclusivity, for women’s rights, for the safety of Americans and human rights, for a worldwide expression of values of empathy and compassion.  

This is What Democracy Looks Like” was the constant refrain of the crowd of mostly women, women of all colors, ages, and sexual identities.  And they mean to stay the course.  



Lawmakers in Congress should know we have our eyes on this Congress, its votes and its leadership.  

Americans, of all races, religions, countries of origin and sexual identity will stand up for themselves and for each other. 

The March was an organizing triumph.  Teresa Shook, a 60+ year old grandmother from Hawaii, put up a Facebook Page on November 9, the day after Trump was elected,  calling for women to march.  Within a day thousands of women had responded.

On January 21, the day after the inauguration, women marched in all fifty states.  Crowd estimates available as of today’s date: DC. 500,000+, NYC 400,000+, Chicago 250,000+, Los Angeles 750,000+, Boston 175,000+, Montpelier 15,000+. 

Women marched in “Sister Marches” in  London, Paris, Amsterdam, Rome, Berlin, Nairobi, Cape Town and Sydney and more.

The Marchers know our democracy is strong.  Our rule of law is strong.  Our history is one of facing and overcoming our problems.  We are not a perfect country but we are a country whose Constitution and  Laws protect us as we work to peacefully make changes to law and culture.  

Marchers are defiant and determined.  They are afraid of what Trump can do with the power of the Presidency behind him. While no knows what will come.  They are committed to the fight. They are the new democratic resistance.






















September 16, 2016

Women Warriors



SUSAN CLOKE
Columnist
Santa Monica Mirror
September 16, 2016


Women Warriors.  Contagious energy and enthusiasm filled the large 1st floor south room of the Veteran’s Administration Hospital in West Los Angeles on Friday, September 9.  Women veterans from all the armed services were celebrating being together.

They had come to be part of the “2nd Annual Women Warrior Freedom Fest.”  The Festival had live music, free hair cuts, and tables loaded with information about medical benefits, housing connections, educational opportunities and staff to answer questions and help.  Congressman Ted Lieu and State Senator Ben Allen’s representatives were there with information on how to contact their offices for assistance in getting their assigned benefits.  The Greater Los Angeles Veterans Administration, HCS Women Veteran Patient Advisory Council organized the event. 

“Never forget both sexes and all people are equal in God’s sight,” were the words of the Chaplain who opened the Festival.  She was followed by a Marine bugler who played Taps, an a cappella performance of the National Anthem by the singer Montie, and an emotionally charged Minute of Silence in honor of the fallen men and women who had died while on active duty.

Most of all they came to have fun, share information and resources, help each other and to tell their stories. 

The oldest veteran was Santa Monican Nancy Cattell, a WWII veteran and a former Santa Monica College Trustee.  The youngest were the veterans now attending Santa Monica College.

Housing.  Blue Butterfly Village, housing for homeless women veterans is a project of Volunteers of America.  They worked with FOCUS (Families Overcoming Under Stress) to get the village up and running.  FOCUS, started a UCLA/NPI had a three year grant which made it possible for the FOCUS staff to provide support for the Blue Butterfly Village.  The Village is a success story which will be a model for other villages and FOCUS will go on to support other projects for women veterans.

“According to the Department of Housing and Urban Development, there
are more than 4,456 homeless female veterans in the U.S., many of whom have children. They account for 8 percent of the nation's 58,000 homeless vets.”

Healthcare for blind veterans.  Talking watches and alarm clocks, calendars and thermostats, even a talking device to tell you the color of the clothes in your closet.  These are provided free of charge to returning veterans who are blind due to combat related trauma and injury through VIST, a specialty clinic of the VA.   In one on one work with rehab specialists Dunia Lara and Ted Zadourian blind veterans are taught to read using special equipment.  The specialists work with patients in the clinic and make home visits.  The goal is to make it possible for the veterans to lead independent lives.

Fatma Batuman MD, FACP
Director Women's Health Clinic
Los Angeles Veteran's Administration
Healthcare for women veterans.  A brochure on the table reads, “VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System is Dedicated to Providing the Highest Quality of Care to Every Woman Veteran.”  It might sound too good to be true.  That is until you meet the Medical Director of the Women’s Health Clinic, Dr. Batuman.  


“I stand up for what I believe.  I take care of patients as whole people.  I teach values,” said the dynamic Doctor.  “We see 8 – 10 thousand women veterans a year.  Patients who left the VA are coming back because of the quality of care in our clinic. 

“We are a comprehensive women’s clinic providing primary care, mammograms, gynecology, maternity care, mental health – anything a women might need.  We provide one stop medical care.  We make it as easy as we can for our veterans.  We hold clinic on Saturdays.”

Art.  2nd Lieutenant Phyllis Miller, a Navy veteran, is now working as an artist.  She was able to attend Design Center because of her veteran status.

Miller is working on a military project series where she brings veterans together and uses art as a way for the veterans to be able to talk about their combat experience.  “It’s my way
of helping and giving tribute to their service,” said Miller.

Army Veteran Roslyn Battle
SMC Faculty John Rogers
Beauty.  John Rogers was one of several teachers and students from the Santa Monica College School of Cosmetology.  They were giving free haircuts as part of the Woman Warriors Fest. The teachers and students also give free haircuts at local shelters and to homeless people who come to the School on Mondays.  

Education.  Santa Monica College had two tables at the event.  Staff offered special help to Veterans and were there to explain the career and technical degree programs, the transfer to 4-year colleges and help with high to enroll at Santa Monica College.

Throughout the event, the women collected information and connected with service providers, networked with each other and enjoyed the music.

Women Warriors Fest organizer and veteran Aretta Gottke promises another festival next year.

The veterans at the Festival were impressive. The spirit in the room was high.  They deserve our tribute and our support and the Festival

What say you?




*If you see a vet on the street that needs help you can contact:

Veteran Angela Russell who now works for the VA in their Community Engagement Reintegration Services.  An ‘outreach worker’ with special training in helping Veterans who are homeless and who need help receiving the benefits they are entitled to as veterans. 

Homeless Veteran’s Outreach Team members are on call
24/7 at 1 877 424 3838  / 1 877 4AID VET













August 1, 2016

Celebrating Medicare’s Birthday & Wishing Medicare for All


Sheila Kuehl and Jackie Goldberg
PNHP Medicare for All Event  July 24  Santa Monica
photo credit Susan Cloke


the Billionaires
photo credit Susan Cloke

Celebrating Medicare’s Birthday &Wishing Medicare for All

Susan Cloke
Columnist









Dressed in tails and evening gowns the singing group, “The Billionaires” poked tuneful barbs charging profiteering by Health Care Companies in the United States.

Listening, sometimes singing along, sitting in a beautiful Santa Monica garden, were a large group of people who had come to celebrate the birthday of Medicare and to support the work of the PNHP CA (Physicians for a National Health Program CA) to open Medicare to all Americans.

Council Members Ted Winterer and Gleam Davis welcomed everyone to the event and spoke of the City Council official statement in support of Single Payer in CA.

State Senator Ben Allen spoke about the successful work of the State Legislature to extend Medicaid to the children of undocumented workers in CA and their ongoing work with the Federal Government for a waiver to allow undocumented workers to be able to buy insurance on the Health Care Exchange.  He also spoke about data showing health care high costs and poor outcomes in the U.S. as compared to Countries with National Health Care.   

Sheila Kuehl, now Los Angeles County Supervisor and formerly a several time Member of the State Legislature, spoke about the history of health care, the beginnings and growth of Medicare and her Bill to establish a Commission responsible for the program for Single Payer Health Care in CA. 

Her Single Payer Bill was introduced several times, to wide support, but was not realized.  She reminded the audience that even if it had been successful it would have needed to go to the voters for approval. 

Kuehl continues to be optimistic saying that she believes incremental changes will continue until “Single Payer becomes inevitable.”

MedicareResources.org outlines the history of Medicare in the U.S from the 1912 platform of President Teddy Roosevelt, which included the idea of a national health plan.  President Franklin Roosevelt had wanted health care to be part of the Social Security Act.

§       In 1945 President Harry Truman called for the creation of a national health insurance fund to be open to all Americans.
§      President John Kennedy made an unsuccessful push for a national health care program for seniors. 
§      Finally, in 1965 President Lyndon Johnson signed legislation that started Americans receiving Medicare health coverage.  President Truman was at the ceremony and received the first Medicare card.
§      The retirement wave of baby boomers was once expected to cause Medicare to become a budget buster. The Congressional Budget Office is now projecting lower increases than once thought, thanks in part to cost savings embedded in ObamaCare.
§      MedicareResources.org records 49,435,610 people as receiving health coverage through a Medicare program in 2014.


PNHP CA focuses their action on creating Medicare for all
and works to support every effort to increase access to health
care for everyone. http://pnhpcalifornia.org/

Jackie Goldberg, former State Assembly Member, former Los Angeles City Council Member and former Los Angeles School Board Member, attended the event to show her support for PNHP and Single Payer and ably led a successful fundraising from the stage.

I believe universal health care, like universal education, will make our democracy better and stronger.  I’m grateful to PNHP and to all the people and organizations working to make quality health care for all a reality.  I am grateful to all the Presidents from Teddy Roosevelt to Barack Obama who moved the cause of universal health care forward. 

In this election year our health care is a front and center issue.  I am grateful to Bernie Sanders. We have all benefited from his commitment to health care for all and for helping our nation to focus on this issue.  

I am grateful to Hillary Clinton.  We have benefitted as a nation by her successful work to make a reality of the plan to insure millions of American children and by her long-standing commitment to achieving health care for all.

& like Sheila Kuehl, I think it’s inevitable.

What Say You?







June 17, 2016

Heal the Bay Honors Felicia Marcus with The Dorothy Green Award
SUSAN CLOKE
Columnist

Felicia Marcus received the prestigious Dorothy Green Award at the Heal the Bay Awards Ceremony held on the beach in Santa Monica on June 9th.

Marcus first knew of Dorothy Green when working for then U.S.  Congressman Tony Beilenson.  Green and Marcus didn’t meet in person until they were both at a Regional Water Quality Control Board meeting in Los Angeles in 1985.  “Within 5 minutes of meeting Dorothy I had agreed to be her lawyer,” said Marcus.

Felicia Marcus

Felicia Marcus is now the Chair of the State Water Board. 
“Right now we are in water crisis but there is plenty of water to meet our real needs in California if we understand how to use it,” said Marcus.

 “Water is wondrous, precious.  We need to be grateful and respect it.  To start, we need to understand it and not take it for granted.





“Urban Californians spend half of our urban water outdoors on ornamental landscapes and lawns – trying to trick our lawns into thinking we’re really in Scotland.

“In the 80’s and 90’s we focused water saving efforts indoor use, on toilets and dishwashers and showers.  In our current drought cycle we are focusing on water use outdoors.

“More importantly we are in a decade of experimentation as we figure out what we could do differently.”

Marcus is an Angelino, born in West Hollywood, going to Birmingham High School in Van Nuys.  When she was in high school sports were still mainly for boys.  “There were special teams for smaller boys to compete, called the ‘B’ and ‘C’ teams.  “The Coaches were working to eliminate those teams so they could have more money for the Varsity teams,” said Marcus.

Marcus learned about the issue from her High School teacher and Marcus thought it was wrong.  With the support of her teachers, Marcus went to the Board of Education to express her support for the ‘B’ and ‘C’ teams.

“I won,” said Marcus, “and I got the very naïve sense that it was pretty easy to win.”

“I didn’t know about East Coast schools and I only knew about Harvard from the movie ‘Love Story’ but I applied.  When the letter came from Harvard I was at camp.  My Aunt Charlotte called and asked if she should open it.  “Yes,” I said.  She did and we both burst out laughing in a combination of relief and happiness.”

“I was a CA girl going from the newness of LA to a school where everything was old.  I loved it.  For me it was a fascinating exposure to all the ways to be and think.”

The Root Tilden Fellowship at NYU attracted Marcus to the law school at NYU.  (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Root-Tilden_Scholarship)  “I was interested in issues of environmental health and public health – issues which affected everyone.  I wanted to become an environmental lawyer.”

Marcus had clerked for Judge Harry Pregerson and then, later, when working at Munger Tolles and Olson, she represented Heal the Bay on the Clean Water Act case requiring LA City to meet water quality standards for treatment plants discharging into Santa Monica Bay.

“Judge Pregerson heard the case and he made us all sit together.  It meant we got to ask our questions of the people and the agencies we saw as the polluters.  It also meant we had to listen to their answers.  There were a myriad of “aha” moments as we began to understand each others’ skills, problems and the potential solutions to protect water quality.”

Marcus has a distinguished resume as an environmental attorney:
working at the firm of Munger Tolles and Olson where she did pro bono work for both Heal the Bay and Planned Parenthood; 
working as the Director of Litigation at Public Counsel
and leveraging volunteer lawyers in public service work;
serving the City of Los Angeles as a Public Works Board Chair with a focus on water quality and recycling;
serving as the EPA Regional Administrator in San Francisco for the EPA during the Clinton Administration 
serving as the chief Operating Officer at the Trust for Public Land.  “In communities across the country TPL connects people to land by creating parks of all kinds;”
working at NRDC as the Western Director.

As Chair of the CA State Water Board Marcus talks about the seriousness of her responsibilities. “Water is part of everything.  It’s essential to life.  We can’t take water for granted. We must use water intelligently so we can meet all our needs.

“Drought has accelerated the conversation about water use.
Climate change accelerates it more.  With even a few degrees rise in temperature we get more rain than snow and that’s a disaster because our snow is about 1/3 of our water storage in a typical year.

“The only way we can approximate that storage capacity is to use our aquifer.  Even in agriculture one farmer’s flood irrigations can be another’s ground water recharge.  It’s a geologically complex issue.

“To deal with the freight train of Climate Change means there can’t be just one solution.  We have to do everything.  Conservation is first.  We also must capture storm water, recharge our aquifers, manage our ground water basins.  We have to make ourselves water resilient.

Felicia Marcus says, “I learned from Heal the Bay and from Dorothy Green that our greatest strength, our power, comes from not just caring about the ocean and the environment but honoring and caring for people.”



Contact Susan Cloke






June 14, 2016

Vigil for Orlando

Rainbow Flag Santa Monica City Hall
ORLANDO
SUSAN CLOKE
Columnist


Santa Monicans gathered in front of City Hall at the end of the day on June 14th to honor and remember the victims of the Orlando shooting.  They called for gun control and for the banning of assault weapons. 

Ross Altman led people in singing ‘We Shall Overcome” and the assembled group joined in and crossed their arms, Civil Rights Movement style, to grasp the hands of the people on either side.

Welcoming remarks were made by Mayor Tony Vazquez and Council Member Ted Winterer.  Welcome also came from Janet McKeithan, the Minister at the Church in Ocean Park, President of the Interfaith Council and the organizer of the Vigil.

Representatives of Christian, Buddhist, Jewish, Muslim, and Bahia faiths spoke of the shared values of all faiths.  The message from each religious leader was one of love and compassion for all people. 

Rabbi Neil Comess Daniels said, “In my tradition we are told ‘You shall not stand idly by the blood of your neighbor.’  It is not a suggestion.  It is a mandate.”

Torie Osborne, political and community leader, spoke of being part of a world-wide community, of demonstrations in London, Paris, Los Angeles, Orlando, Tokyo.  The Eiffel Tower, she said, was lit the colors of the LGBT flag.  http://www.politico.eu/article/eiffel-tower-orlando-lights-mass-shooting-anne-hidalgo-isil-terrorism/ 

Osborne spoke of the compassion of the people of Orlando, saying, “Straight or gay, the people stood in the blistering son for over 5 hours to donate blood to the wounded victims.”

Community leader Lucy Taylor read her poetry, written for Orlando.

“We are that sister, brother, man, cousin, friend to those beautiful souls that were robbed of their life and stolen from our hearts.

“We are that survivor of your wounds and will continue to stand strong with our LGBT Community.  Together we will continue to live in freedom and love.”

The vigil concluded with the names of the Orlando victims being read out and a resonant bell sounding with the reading of each name.   

Names of the victims. City of Orlando

Theresa Bonpane and Ross Altman
The Santa Monica Vigil for Orlando was over, but the words of religious and community leader Theresa Bonpane were remembered, “We join with tens of thousands of people all over the world,” and people left City Hall knowing this was not over.